Pizza restaurants

D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs

4.6 239 reviews Closed 241 Allegheny St, Jersey Shore, PA 17740, United States

Discover this place

D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs, located in Jersey Shore, PA, has quickly become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. With a focus on hearty pizza and subs, customers rave about the generous portions and welcoming atmosphere.

Reviewers like Quiet Moon1993 shared a delightful experience with a bacon-loaded BLT, complemented by sweet peppers. Many patrons highlight the friendly service, with Daniel Hunter stating, “Always have great food and friendly servers.” The customer interactions add a personal touch that enhances the overall dining experience.

Robert Gallego noted the impressive size and flavor of the large combination sub, boasting a selection of meats, cheeses, and the restaurant's signature spicy cherry pepper sauce. Meanwhile, Karen Shaffer praised the cheese cosmo as the best she’s had in the area, highlighting the meticulous preparation and delightful seasonings.

With fast service and fair prices, jessica hill encourages trying the chicken cheese steak for a filling meal at a great value. The combination of quality food, friendly staff, and cozy ambiance makes D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs a must-visit for anyone craving delicious pizza or subs in Jersey Shore.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs before visiting.

Reviews for D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs

4.6

239 reviews

100%

17%

Review highlights

Based on 239 reviews

Reviews for D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs consistently highlight the restaurant’s generous portion sizes and flavorful menu offerings, particularly their subs and specialty sandwiches. Customers frequently praise the quality and freshness of the ingredients, noting well-seasoned and satisfying options such as their signature sauces and ample toppings. The friendly and attentive service, often described as pleasant and polite, contributes positively to the overall dining experience. Additionally, patrons appreciate the reasonable pricing and quick service, making it a favored spot for both casual meals and quick stops. The welcoming atmosphere and consistent food quality position D'Agostino's as a reliable choice in the Jersey Shore area.

Quiet Moon1993

Jun 05, 2025

My bf and I went there this evening while we were at the firehouse next door. It was when the phone systems went down after the storm. I got a BLT and I was happily surprised to see A TON of bacon on it. It was so good, especially with the sweet peppers. And the ladies were so nice. Definitely going back!

Daniel Hunter

Jun 02, 2025

Always have great food and friendly servers.

Robert Gallego

May 25, 2025

I was passing through on my delivery route and stopped in for the first time. Woman at the counter was very pleasant and extremely polite. I ordered the large combination sub and when it came out could not believe how big it was, not to mention packed with meat, cheese and veggies. She said they have their own cherry pepper sauce that is spicy and sure enough, HOT!!! The way i like it. Very quaint and clean spot. Highly recommend this place.

Karen Shaffer

May 20, 2025

Omg I haven’t had a great cosmo in a very long time. I thought I’d give this place a try. It was the absolute best cheese cosmo I’ve had within a 20 mile radius! My entire experience with this establishment was far more than amazing!!! It started with a most pleasant young female who took my order, to the very tasteful seasonings, and toasted to perfection.

jessica hill

May 02, 2025

Fast service, amazing price, really amazing food! Try there chicken cheese steak 14inch really good and filling I get raw onions, tomatoes, mayonnaise and sometimes a little extra and toasted! I get there nuggets the 5 count and is really good You can pick any sauce and same with the Sandwich any toppings and u can remove something if you don't like and I get a soda that all comes up too 22.05 dollars but they doo have a small size for the sandwich that would be alot more cheaper but over all its will worth it everytime I go! Information about there food and place hope this help and have a bless day!

Shana Montgomery

Apr 26, 2025

We eat at D’Agostinos almost every time we are in town. Their prices are excellent, portions are large, and the people have always been super friendly. We love the cheeseburger subs!

Justin Wenger

Mar 20, 2025

Always delicious and friendly service.

Sixpack kid

Mar 18, 2025

Very friendly place best food in jersey shore,Tom